The Rum Howler Awards – The Whisky Wrap-up
Posted by Arctic Wolf on October 23, 2010
And today I reach the last of my Rum Howler Awards Postings presenting the ‘grand prize’ awards for best whiskies I have tasted over the past year. As with the rum, I wanted to be completely fair about things so I brought in some help and had the final tasting sessions done by panel rather than by myself alone.
All final tastings were done in a blind format. The panel members were not even tasting the same spirits at the same time. The whiskies were ranked by each panel member, and then the rankings were compared to choose the best spirit for each category.
Unlike the Rum awards which were based upon age and price, the whisky awards were based solely on price. I allowed for a bit of leeway ($10.00) when it came to imported whiskies as I understand the costs of shipping into my locale from other parts of the world.
The decision to make the determining factor, price rather than age, was based upon the sheer volume of whiskies with no age statement in my market. However once that decision was made, it was a foregone conclusion that Alberta Premium 25 Yr Old Limited Edition would waltz away with the first award. In the under $40.00 price range there just isn’t a better whisky in the world. The good news for the competitors is that this whisky has pretty much sold out and will not be in the competition next year. The bad news for the competitors is that Alberta Premium 30 Year Old is apparently on its way.
The Highland Park 12 Year Old Whisky is my go to whisky when I want a nice aromatic peated whisky in the middle of the cold spells in winter. I was immensely satisfied when the panel verified my thoughts that this is a world-class spirit. The Johnny Walker Black, The Alberta Premium 25, and the Wiser’s 18 Year Old were all very strong competitors in what was the closest race for an award in this series. If you began your whisky collection with these four spirits, you would do yourself no wrong.
The Rum Howler Award for Best Whisky (Any Price)
Four panel members each chose a different whisky in the blind tastings. But when all the scores were analyzed the Black Art from Bruichladdich was deemed to be the most popular. I found it interesting that the Irish whiskey from Cooley’s scored so well. It seems that every time this bottle is opened it gains new converts. I also found it interesting that the Wiser’s 18 and the Highland Park 12 scored much higher than many more expensive offerings.
And there we have the final “Grand Prize” Rum Howler Awards for Whiskies! Here is a summary of today’s Awards:
The Rum Howler Award for Best Whisky under $40.00, Alberta Premium Rye 25Yr Old
The Rum Howler Award for Best Whisky under $80.00, Highland Park 12
The Rum Howler Award for Best Whisky (Any Price), Bruichladdich Black Art
All of my 2010 Whisky Awards can be found on this summary page:
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.