It is hard to believe that my blog has been online for one year now. I have sampled over 70 bottles of rum, and over 40 bottles of whisky in that time, (and built 4 new bookcases to hold all the bottles). Of course the question I always get from people who read the blog is, “So what is your favourite Rum or Whisky?”
Today I am going to attempt to answer the question by presenting the first annual Rum Howler Awards! Of course, everyone should understand that I must introduce some provisos when I make the claim to tell you what I like best. I obviously cannot judge any spirit which I have not tasted during the past year. I also cannot make a comparative final tasting when the sample I received for my review, was so small that I now have none left to compare. Fortunately, in most cases I saved a small sample of my favourite rums and whiskies just for this purpose, as to be honest my Rum howler Awards have been in the works for a while now. So without more adieu perhaps I will begin.
……………………………………………………………………………………………………..
The first Rum Howler Award is presented for the Best White Rum in a Daiquiri (I consider the daiquiri to be the quintessential cocktail for white rum).
And the Winner is:
Honorable mention to El Dorado 3 Year, and Bermudez Ron Viejo Blanco.
Judging this category involved me making me a daiquiri using each nominated rum and doing a side by side comparison on a hot summer evening. The Kōloa daiquiri was the runaway favourite. A surprising result perhaps, but then again this rum is so clean and pure perhaps I should have anticipated its magnificence in a classic cocktail like the daiquiri!
……………………………………………………………………………………………………..
The next award is for the best overall white rum. White rum has recently experienced a substantial category change where we have the new so-called premium white rums which have been aged for up to six years (perhaps more) and then filtered clear to give the rum a superior sipping and mixing profile. This means a second award for White Rum is in order.
The Best White Rum Overall:
Honourable mention to Bermudez Ron Viejo Blanco, and Highwood Imported White who were the other nominees.
For this category I considered not only the flavour in a daiquiri but also the overall flavour in The Cuba Libre, and the Mojito, (the triumvirate of classic white rum cocktails). I took that overall score and gave it 50 % of the weighting, then I also compared the taste of each rum neat which accounted for the other 50 percent of the score.
……………………………………………………………………………………………………..
The spiced/flavoured category of rum is all the rage right now. For my awards I decided I would include the so-called Black Rums and the dark Navy Rums in this category as they appear to my palate to be essentially the same as flavoured rums.
The Rum Howler award for the Best Spiced or Flavoured Rum is:
Honourable mention goes to Juan Santos Coffee Rum,and Lambs Blacksheep Rum.
Of course this category was difficult to judge based upon the extreme differences in the rums involved. So I could not follow a rigorous format. I decided to go to the producers websites and see if i could build the recommended cocktail for each spirit. I balanced this off with the flavour drinking the spirit neat. It was a very close battle between the Gosling’s Black Seal which was tremendous in a Dark ‘n Stormy versus the Juan Santos Coffee Rum which is a great sipping dessert rum.
……………………………………………………………………………………………………..
Now I am going to turn my attention to Whisky. Anyone who has read my blog realizes that I love to mix cocktails and bar drinks. I believe that the vast majority of whisky drinkers do the same. The Horse’s Neck (Whisky and ginger-ale) is the quintessential bar drink that I like to serve, and as such a suitable drink to use for judging the mixability of whisky.
Therefore, I created The Rum Howler Award for the Best Whisky in a Horse’s Neck:
Honourable mention to Hiram Walker Special Old and Centennial 10 Year Old.
I loved judging this one. I made small whisky and ginger ale drinks from just about every one of my Canadian Whiskies and tasted them over several nights to arrive at the last three. (I also tried several American, Irish and Scotch Whiskies as well but they just didn’t measure up.) The final three were judged side by side in a final evening of pure enjoyment.
……………………………………………………………………………………………………..
Next I turned my attention to Blended Whisky. I did not discriminate between age, or cost. If the whisky was labeled as a blend it qualified for an award.
The Rum Howler Award for the Best Blended Whisky goes to:
Honourable mention goes to Johnny Walker Black Label, and Forty Creek Portwood Reserve.
I decided to judge this award based first upon the whiskies flavour in two classic whisky cocktails, The Old Fashioned, and the Manhattan. 50 percent of the score was derived from the flavour the whisky presented in these cocktails. The other 50 % of the score was derived from the flavour the whisky displayed when drank neat. I sampled three Scottish whiskies, Johnnie Walker Black Label, Johnnie Walker Gold Label, and Old Parr Superior. As well I sampled three other Canadian Whiskies, Forty Creek Portwood Reserve, Crown Royal Cask No. 16, and of course Wiser’s 18 Years Old.
The Wiser’s 18 Year Old won by the slimmest of margins in a final taste off with a whisky which continues to surprise me, Johnnie Walker Black Label.
……………………………………………………………………………………………………..
Of Course if I select the best Blended Whisky, I should also select the best Single Grain Whisky. Included in this category is any whisky which is made from a single grain with the exclusion of Single Malt Whiskies.
The Rum Howler Award for the Best Single Grain Whisky goes to:
Honourable mention to Alberta Premium Rye 25Yr Old, and Century Reserve 21 Yr Old.
I decided to judge this award in the same manner as I judged the best blended Whisky. Based first upon the whisky flavour in the two classic whisky cocktails, The Old Fashioned, and the Manhattan. Then based upon the flavour the whisky displayed when drank neat. I was very surprised when the side by side comparison revealed a winner which was not Alberta Premium 25 yr Old (one of one of my personal favourites) . Instead the Greenore Single Grain Whisky from Ireland reigned supreme!
……………………………………………………………………………………………………..
And there you have it, the first six Rum Howler Awards:
The Best White Rum in a Daiquiri, Kōloa White Rum.
The Best White Rum Overall, El Dorado 3 Year.
The Best Whisky in a Horses Neck, Gibson’s Finest 12 YR.
The Best Blended Whisky, Wiser’s 18 Years Old.
The Best Spiced or Flavoured Rum, Gosling’s Black Seal.
The Best Single Grain Whisky, Greenore Single Grain Irish Whiskey.
More Rum Howler Awards will be posted over the next several days as I continue to award the rums and the whiskies which pleased my palate the most since I began my blog a year ago. Stay tuned!
Admiral Nelson’s Spiced Rum is bottled at 70 proof (35 % alc/vol). The Rum is bottled in the U.S. by Admiral Nelson Rum Company of Missouri. The bottle I reviewed would have been aged in oak for at least one year as per Canadian Law. The Admiral Nelson Rum website indicates that savory spices are used to create the blend with a hint of sweet vanilla.
The Rum Howler Blog 